Andrew Charles Stuart 1831-1898 Series, bulk: 1860 - 1880, 1865 - 1998
Scope and Contents
The Alexander Charles Stuart 1831-1898 series preserves original documents from Stuart’s life and secondary source materials documenting recent reassessments of Stuart’s career. The core of the series is 61 letters written to Stuart between 1865 to 1887, a majority of which are from the Harlan & Hollingsworth Company of Wilmington, Delaware. The collection contains unique ephemera, such as Stuart’s commuter passes for the Wilmington-Thurlow Railway, and a handwritten agreement between Stuart and H. T. Gause of the Harlan & Hollingsworth Company regarding the construction and testing of Stuart’s model for a railroad “self-acting station indicator.”
This series was assembled by historian Paul Preston Davis between 2001-2011. Most of the collection was acquired by Davis through purchase from Robert Fleck of Oak Knoll Books, New Castle, DE, in March of 1996. Fleck acquired many of the letters from Allen Shiek, a Delaware-based dentist, and past Director of the Archaeology Society of Delaware (1958-1960). As far as the provenance of the Stuart letters is concerned, it is unknown as to where Fleck acquired these from. Additional letters dated May 14, 1865, October 12, 1874, and April 10, 1883, were acquired by Davis from Wilmington artist, and former attorney, Charles Allmond. It is unknown as to where Allmond acquired these letters.
The research materials within this series were compiled by Davis and collector Julie Colflesh and include notes on Stuart’s work alongside photocopies of nineteenth- and twentieth-century newspaper articles that reference the artist. Other materials feature exhibitions of Stuart’s ship portraits and marine paintings, such as the 1956 exhibition, Stuart (1831-1898) held at John Wanamaker’s in Wilmington, Delaware and Alexander Charles Stuart: Ship Portraits and Marine Paintings, held at the Brandywine Museum of Art in 1997.
Davis’s interest in Alexander Charles Stuart has connection to his interest in Wilmington business and industry such as the Harlan & Holllingsworth Company.
Dates
- Creation: Majority of material found within 1860 - 1880
- Creation: 1865 - 1998
Creator
- Colflesh, Julie, 1997 (active) (Person)
- Davis, Paul Preston, 1931-2021 (Person)
- Gause,, J.T., 1887 (active) (Person)
- Harlan & Hollingsworth Company of Wilmington, Delaware (Organization)
- Smith, T.B., 1882 (active) (Person)
- Stuart,, Alexander Charles, 1831-1898 (Person)
Conditions Governing Access
This collection is open for researchers by appointment only. Please contact the Research Center for information on access and research.
Alexander Charles Stuart (1831-1898)
Alexander Charles Stuart 1831-1898 was born in Campbeltown, Scotland and raised in Glasgow. According to his own account, Stuart studied engineering and medicine in Scotland and served in the British Army. In 1861, he emigrated to the United States and joined the United States Marines. During the American Civil War, Stuart was second Assistant Engineer in the Union Navy. While serving in this position, he made watercolor sketches of naval ships and sea battles, and painted oil on canvas works such as Naval Engagement Between Rebel Ram Albemarle and Union Vessels (1864). After the war, he settled in Philadelphia, and then later in Chester, Pennsylvania. He married and had a total of eight children.
Like Glasgow, the cities of Philadelphia and Chester, Pennsylvania, as well as Wilmington, Delaware, boasted robust shipbuilding industries. Stuart was hired to paint ship portraits for documentation and advertising by William Cramp & Sons in Philadelphia, John Roach & Sons and its child company the Delaware River Shipbuilding and Ironworks in Chester, Pennsylvania, and The Harlan & Hollingsworth Company in Wilmington, Delaware.
Stuart learned oil and watercolor painting by copying from magazines, popular reproductions, and other artists’ work. To ensure a steady income, he frequently replicated his own work of subjects that proved popular with local clients.
Sometime around 1880, Stuart abandoned the ship as a subject in his work. During the final decades of his life, Stuart suffered from alcoholism and intermittent poverty. For a time, he associated with the landscape painter Henry Lea Tatnall and other Wilmington artists, but ultimately ended these connections. Stuart attempted unsuccessfully to market his paintings in New York, and, during a brief stint in Florida, sought work by claiming to be a physician before finally returning to his family in Wilmington. In the 1890s, he moved to Camden, New Jersey, with his daughter, Amy Moon, and died there in 1898. After his death, Stuart’s personal reputation in Wilmington subdued serious interest in his work. Two exhibitions, one at John Wanamaker’s department store in 1954, and another at the Brandywine Museum of Art in 1997, produced publications that brought recognition to Stuart’s place in the genre of American ship portraiture and Brandywine region art history.
Extent
0.427 Linear Feet (1 box)
Language of Materials
English
Abstract
This series primarily features correspondence and business papers of the Wilmington ship portraitist and marine painter, Alexander Charles Stuart 1831-1898. The collection additionally contains catalogs featuring Stuart and his work, as well as research materials on Stuart gathered by the donor, Paul Preston Davis, from various sources including Wilmington researcher Julie Colflesh.
Arrangement
Within the original binder, contents were arranged into six sections marked by dividers: “Letters to Stuart,” “Miscellaneous Papers,” “Miscellaneous,” “Julie’s Research,” “Stuart Exhibition 1956,” and “Stuart Exhibition 1997.” Naming conventions for this arrangement derive from the original divider titles, included in the “Binder Contents” folder. These divisions were replicated in the following grouping arrangement:
- Letters to Stuart, Folders 1-4: Includes original correspondence to Stuart. Two letters located in folder 1 are not addressed directly to Stuart but do refer to him and his work.
- Miscellaneous Papers, Folder 5: Includes manuscripts and ephemera written by or relating to Stuart.
- Miscellaneous, Folder 6: Includes secondary sources, such as articles referencing Stuart and photographs taken of him.
- Julie's Research, Folder 7: Includes research on Stuart’s life and career compiled by Julie Colflesh and shared with Davis.
- Stuart Exhibition 1956, Folders 8-9: Includes materials related to the 1956 exhibition, Stuart (1831-1898), held at the John Wanamaker Store in Wilmington, Delaware.
- Stuart Exhibition 1997, Folders 10-11: Includes materials related to the 1997 exhibition, Alexander Charles Stuart: Ship Portraits and Marine Paintings, held at the Brandywine Museum of Art in 1997.
- Binder Contents, Folder 12: This folder was created by the Research Center staff, and contains the dividers, bookplate, and spine label from the binder.
Immediate Source of Acquisition
Gift of Paul Preston Davis, 2011
Accession number: 41083.1
Accruals
Part of numerous donations made by Paul Preston Davis; No further accruals expected.
Sources
O’Hara, Virginia. “Alexander Charles Stuart: Ship Portraits and Marine Paintings” Chadds Ford, PA: Brandywine River Museum of Art. 1997.
Leigh Rifenburg (Chief Curator at Delaware Historical Society) in discussion with Bri Cronin, January 2025.
Series Author
Original finding aid for this series written by Christoforos Sassaris, 2021. Edited by Lillian Kinney, 2024, Bri Cronin, 2024.
Processing Information
This series was processed, and the original finding aid was written by summer intern Christoforos Sassaris in 2021. The collection was received in the donor’s original three-ring binder broken into sections, with materials enclosed in polyester sleeves. During a 2024 finding aid reassessment project, revisions and updates were made to the finding aid by Manager Lillian Kinney, 2024, to comply with DACS formatting. Summer intern Bri Cronin in 2024 rehoused the materials to an archival box. During the transfer process, the original order of the binder and its naming conventions were maintained. An inventory of the correspondence addressed to or about Stuart was completed, and any evident staples and metal fasteners were removed.
During a reprocessing project that began in 2024, the materials were identified as part of a greater series of donations made by Paul Preston Davis. The Alexander Charles Stuart collection was changed from a stand-alone collection to a series under the Paul Preston Davis Collection to maintain better provenance.
Accession No. 41083.1
Subject
- William Cramp & Sons Ship and Engine Building Co. (Organization)
- Delaware River Iron Ship Building and Engine Works . John Roach & Sons. Delaware River Shipbuilding and Ironworks (Organization)
- United States Shipbuilding Co. (Organization)
- Harlan & Hollingsworth Company of Wilmington, Delaware (Organization)
Repository Details
Part of the Walter & Leonore Annenberg Research Center - Archives & Special Collections Repository
1 Hoffman's Mill Road
PO Box 141
Chadds Ford PA 19317 United States
610-388-8310
research@brandywine.org
